Two refills, two different scratching surfaces
If your cat's scratcher is looking worn, a replacement pad can extend its life—but only if you pick the right one. The Catit Play Refill Scratch Pad and the Vesper Scratchy Sisal Replacement Pad are both refills, yet they differ in material, size, and the furniture they fit. This comparison breaks down the supplied facts so you can match a refill to your existing setup.
Material and dimensions at a glance
The most obvious difference is the scratching surface: cardboard versus sisal. That choice affects how the pad feels to your cat and how it wears, though the supplied information does not include durability ratings or cat preferences.
- Catit Play Refill Scratch Pad: Cardboard scratch pad; dimensions 4 × 23.5 × 26 cm.
- Vesper Scratchy Sisal Replacement Pad: Sisal pad; size 20 × 20 cm.
Catit Play Refill Scratch Pad: designed for a specific toy
- Catit Play Refill Scratch Pad: Genuine Catit replacement part designed for use with the Catit Play Circuit Ball Toy With Scratch Pad (43000). This refill is not a universal pad—it is intended for that specific Catit toy, so check your model before ordering.

Catit Play Refill Scratch Pad - Catit Play Refill Scratch Pad: Dimensions: 4 × 23.5 × 26 cm. These measurements help you confirm the pad will fit the intended toy's scratch area.
- Catit Play Refill Scratch Pad: Refill cardboard scratch pad. Cardboard offers a different scratching texture than sisal; the supplied information does not state how long it lasts.
Vesper Scratchy Sisal Replacement Pad: made for Vesper furniture
- Vesper Scratchy Sisal Replacement Pad 52170 - 20 x 20cm: Replacement for: Vesper High Base, Vesper Tower. This pad is intended for those specific Vesper products, so it is not a one-size-fits-all refill.

Vesper Scratchy Sisal Replacement Pad 52170 - 20 x 20cm - Vesper Scratchy Sisal Replacement Pad 52170 - 20 x 20cm: Size: 20 × 20 cm. The square dimensions suit the designated Vesper furniture; compare with your existing pad before buying.
- Vesper Scratchy Sisal Replacement Pad 52170 - 20 x 20cm: Easy to attach with hook-and-loop tape. The supplied information describes hook-and-loop attachment, which may simplify swapping the pad.
- Vesper Scratchy Sisal Replacement Pad 52170 - 20 x 20cm: Durable sisal pad. Sisal is a plant fiber often used for scratching surfaces; the supplied information does not quantify durability.
How to choose between cardboard and sisal
Your existing scratcher dictates the choice. If you own the Catit Play Circuit Ball Toy With Scratch Pad (43000), the Catit Play Refill Scratch Pad is the matching refill. If you have a Vesper High Base or Vesper Tower, the Vesper Scratchy Sisal Replacement Pad is the listed replacement.
Material preference also matters. Cardboard and sisal feel different under claws, but the supplied information does not include wear rates or cat preferences, so observe your cat's scratching habits. Some cats prefer one texture over another, and you may need to try both to see which gets used more.
What the supplied information leaves open
The records do not state how long either pad lasts, whether the cardboard is reversible, or if the Vesper pad fits other Vesper models beyond the High Base and Tower. They also do not include care instructions such as cleaning or replacement frequency. For those details, check the product packaging or contact the manufacturer. Use the dimensions and compatibility notes above as your primary guide, and measure your existing pad before ordering to avoid a poor fit.



