Catit Creamy Ice Tray: Frozen Cat Treats and Portion Tips
By Real Pet Store | Published: 2026-10-16
Category: Product Reviews
See how the Catit Creamy heart-shaped ice tray turns creamy treats into frozen cat treats, plus portion rules, filling tips, and which cats should skip it.
Quick answer
The Catit Creamy Heart-Shaped Silicone Ice Tray is a simple six-cavity mold for turning lickable cat treats into frozen treats. Fill it with Catit Creamy, smooth the top, freeze for a few hours, then push the silicone to pop out heart-shaped portions. It is best for cats that already eat creamy treats, and it is not a meal replacement or a good fit for cats that gulp or have sensitive teeth.
How the Catit Creamy ice tray works
The tray measures 130 x 150 x 11mm and has six heart-shaped cavities. The supplied steps are straightforward: fill with Catit Creamy, smooth with a spoon, freeze for a few hours, push down on the silicone to release the treats, then serve. Because the tray is silicone, you do not need to twist or run it under water to release the treats; pressing from the back pops each heart out. That makes it easier to freeze one or two portions at a time rather than committing a whole batch.
Portion rules before you freeze
Frozen treats should stay treats. A practical rule is to count each heart as a portion and cap them at one or two hearts per day for an average adult cat, then reduce the main meal slightly if your cat gains weight. If you are using Webbox Lick-e-Lix with Milk & Yoghurt, each pack contains 7 x 10g sachets with no added sugar, so one sachet can fill part of the tray and the rest can be refrigerated for later. Do not refreeze thawed creamy treats.
Filling and flavor options
Catit Creamy is the intended filling, but you can also use Webbox Lick-e-Lix with Milk & Yoghurt for a yoghurt-like texture. If your cat takes crushed tablets in a soft treat, you can disguise them in a single heart, but keep that heart separate from the rest so you know which one has the medication. For a dog in the house, Natures Deli Salmon Paste Pouch 100g is a grain-free, gluten-free paste that can be squeezed onto kibble or into toys, but it is a dog treat and should not be used in the cat tray unless your vet says otherwise.
Freezing, serving, and cleaning
Freeze the filled tray flat for a few hours. Once solid, you can leave the hearts in the tray or transfer them to a freezer bag. Serve one heart at a time in a shallow dish so it thaws slowly; cats that eat too fast can get brain freeze just like people. Wash the silicone tray by hand with warm soapy water and let it air dry before the next batch. Do not put the tray in the dishwasher unless the manufacturer says it is dishwasher safe, which is not stated in the supplied facts.
Decision rules for buying the Catit Creamy ice tray
- Buy it if your cat already eats creamy treats: The tray is designed around Catit Creamy, so the easiest path is to use the treat your cat already accepts. If your cat turns its nose up at lickable treats, the tray will not change that. Match the tray to a treat your cat already likes.
- Skip it if your cat gulps or has dental sensitivity: Frozen hearts are cold and firm. Cats that swallow treats whole or have sensitive teeth may do better with the same treat served at room temperature. Cold texture is the main trade-off, not the mold itself.
- Choose silicone over rigid plastic for easy release: The supplied steps rely on pushing the silicone to pop the treats out. Rigid trays often need twisting or warm water, which can melt the edges. Silicone is the practical choice for small, soft frozen treats.
- Keep the batch small and label medication hearts: Six cavities is enough for a few days of treats, not a month. If you hide a crushed tablet in one heart, mark it or freeze it in a separate bag so you do not mix it up. Small batches and clear labeling prevent overfeeding and mix-ups.
Product facts
- Catit Creamy Heart-Shaped Silicone Ice Tray: Heart-shaped ice tray with six heart-shaped cavities; dimensions 130 x 150 x 11mm; fill with Catit Creamy, freeze for a few hours, then push the silicone to pop treats out. The six small cavities let you freeze single portions instead of a whole batch, and the silicone release means no chiseling or soaking.
- Webbox Lick-e-Lix with Milk & Yoghurt Cat Treats: Webbox Lick-e-Lix with Milk & Yoghurt is a soft, lickable yoghurt-style treat sold as 7 x 10g sachets with no added sugar. The sachets are easy to squeeze into the tray cavities and the no-added-sugar formula keeps the frozen treat from becoming a sugar bomb.
- Natures Deli Salmon Paste Pouch 100g: Natures Deli Salmon Paste Pouch 100g is a complementary grain-free, gluten-free, hypoallergenic dog treat in a screw-cap pouch that stores in the fridge for up to 7 days. If you also have a dog, this paste is a multi-use topper or toy filler, but it is not a cat treat and should not go in the cat ice tray.
Who the Catit Creamy ice tray is for
Best for
- Cats that already eat Catit Creamy or Webbox Lick-e-Lix and enjoy licking treats from a dish
- Owners who want a simple homemade frozen cat treat routine with six small portions
- Households that need a dog-safe paste for a separate pet, using Natures Deli Salmon Paste for the dog
Not for
- Cats that gulp treats or have dental sensitivity that makes cold food uncomfortable
- Owners looking for a complete meal or a way to replace balanced cat food
- Anyone who needs a dishwasher-safe tray, since dishwasher safety is not stated in the supplied facts
